Difference between revisions of "Talk:Trinley Shingta"
BenTremblay (talk | contribs) m |
BenTremblay (talk | contribs) m (A tale of Karma_Trinley_Rinpoche) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''Format for lineage holders' names?'''<br /> | '''Format for lineage holders' names?'''<br /> | ||
| − | Something I noticed with regards to material concerning the Dakpo Kagyu lineage was that pages in [[Karmapa]] have been named as, for example: [[1st_Karmapa]]. (At variance with that, on the [[Karmapa]] page, we find 12th [[Tai_Situ_Rinpoche|Tai Situ Rinpoche]], pointing to Tai_Situ_Rinpoche. p.s. [[Third_Karmapa]] redirects to [[3rd_Karmapa]], which is neat. But [[Rangjung_Dorje]] also points to [[Jigme_Lingpa]] as disambiguation, which page only refers to [[Ranjung_Dorje]]. My point | + | Something I noticed with regards to material concerning the Dakpo Kagyu lineage was that pages in [[Karmapa]] have been named as, for example: [[1st_Karmapa]]. (At variance with that, on the [[Karmapa]] page, we find 12th [[Tai_Situ_Rinpoche|Tai Situ Rinpoche]], pointing to Tai_Situ_Rinpoche. p.s. [[Third_Karmapa]] redirects to [[3rd_Karmapa]], which is neat. But [[Rangjung_Dorje]] also points to [[Jigme_Lingpa]] as disambiguation, which page only refers to '''[[Ranjung_Dorje]]'''. And search for [[Karma Trinlepa]] fails, though by using history I looked under "Students" on [[7th_Karmapa]] and there found [[Karma_Trinley_Rinpoche_I]] ... which includes a link to [[Karma_Trinley_Rinpoche]], where we find a list of 4. My point <nowiki>[no diss intended!]</nowiki> is this: imprecision obscures simple typos; confidence is an aspect of cognition. --KC:)<br /> |
| − | Here we have [[Trinley_Shingta]]; in keeping with the above I'd expect to have (also?) [[7th Gyalwang Drukpa | + | Here on this page we have [[Trinley_Shingta]]; in keeping with the above I'd expect to have (also?) [[7th Gyalwang Drukpa]] Rinpoche. To my mind 7th [[Gyalwang Drukpa]] Rinpoche has another purpose and another result.<br /> |
''What '''concerns''' me is this'': that wiki function fails to give a page for [[7th Gyalwang Drukpa]] just as it now fails on [[Karmapa Khakyap Dorje]].<br /> | ''What '''concerns''' me is this'': that wiki function fails to give a page for [[7th Gyalwang Drukpa]] just as it now fails on [[Karmapa Khakyap Dorje]].<br /> | ||
''What '''occurs''' to me'' after applying OR is: the form [[7th Gyalwang Drukpa]] and [[12th Tai Situ]] provides a minimal resolution that is secure. --[[User:BenTremblay|KC:]] 04:43, 10 July 2009 (UTC) | ''What '''occurs''' to me'' after applying OR is: the form [[7th Gyalwang Drukpa]] and [[12th Tai Situ]] provides a minimal resolution that is secure. --[[User:BenTremblay|KC:]] 04:43, 10 July 2009 (UTC) | ||
Latest revision as of 02:32, 10 July 2009
Format for lineage holders' names?
Something I noticed with regards to material concerning the Dakpo Kagyu lineage was that pages in Karmapa have been named as, for example: 1st_Karmapa. (At variance with that, on the Karmapa page, we find 12th Tai Situ Rinpoche, pointing to Tai_Situ_Rinpoche. p.s. Third_Karmapa redirects to 3rd_Karmapa, which is neat. But Rangjung_Dorje also points to Jigme_Lingpa as disambiguation, which page only refers to Ranjung_Dorje. And search for Karma Trinlepa fails, though by using history I looked under "Students" on 7th_Karmapa and there found Karma_Trinley_Rinpoche_I ... which includes a link to Karma_Trinley_Rinpoche, where we find a list of 4. My point [no diss intended!] is this: imprecision obscures simple typos; confidence is an aspect of cognition. --KC:)
Here on this page we have Trinley_Shingta; in keeping with the above I'd expect to have (also?) 7th Gyalwang Drukpa Rinpoche. To my mind 7th Gyalwang Drukpa Rinpoche has another purpose and another result.
What concerns me is this: that wiki function fails to give a page for 7th Gyalwang Drukpa just as it now fails on Karmapa Khakyap Dorje.
What occurs to me after applying OR is: the form 7th Gyalwang Drukpa and 12th Tai Situ provides a minimal resolution that is secure. --KC: 04:43, 10 July 2009 (UTC)